TAX ALERT | March 31, 2022
by RSM US LLP
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled on an issue of first impression, holding that exporters of crude oil were entitled to a refund of section 4611 oil spill excise tax paid. The case was decided in a 2-1 decision, with the second judge concurring only with the result and not the opinion itself.
In Trafigura Trading LLC. v. United States, (No. 21-20127, decided March 24, 2022) the Fifth Circuit ruled that the government must refund $4.5 million of section 4611(b) oil spill excise tax. The purpose of this excise tax is to fund cleanups and pollution research. The court ruled that these taxes were not permissible under the US constitution’s export clause.
Trafigura, a commodity trading company that purchases and exports crude oil from the United States, had sued for a refund of the tax it paid for the Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund, which helps companies and the government address and prepare for oil spills. The tax was calculated at eight or nine cents per barrel, depending on the year, for domestic crude oil “exported from the United States.
The court held, by delving into its views on the founding fathers’ intentions, that it was correct to award Trafigura the refund. Since the fee was based on how much domestic crude oil is exported, rather than the costs of cleaning up oil spills, it fell under the export clause’s blanket ban of states imposing export taxes and levies in the U.S. Constitution.
However, the dissenting judge pointed out that genuine issues remain concerning whether section 4611 imposes a legitimate user fee. The judge said the export clause does not rule out user fees if they lack the attributes of a tax or duty, but rather are designed to compensate the government for services, facilities or benefits. Then, the dissent argued that Trafigura was not eligible for the tax refund because the fee was more like compensation for services, less like a tax.
Washington National Tax observations
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals decision in Trafigura is significant because it is an issue of first impression. Holding that a long-standing statute is unconstitutional is a significant issue for the industry. To the extent that others in the industry are exporting crude oil, refund claims of the oil spill excise tax should be considered. It remains to be seen whether the IRS will acquiesce this issue or whether it will continue to litigation, either by a request to review the case en banc by the entire Fifth Circuit or by an appeal to the Supreme Court.
This article was written by Deborah Gordon and originally appeared on 2022-03-31.
2022 RSM US LLP. All rights reserved.
The information contained herein is general in nature and based on authorities that are subject to change. RSM US LLP guarantees neither the accuracy nor completeness of any information and is not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for results obtained by others as a result of reliance upon such information. RSM US LLP assumes no obligation to inform the reader of any changes in tax laws or other factors that could affect information contained herein. This publication does not, and is not intended to, provide legal, tax or accounting advice, and readers should consult their tax advisors concerning the application of tax laws to their particular situations. This analysis is not tax advice and is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for purposes of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on any taxpayer.
RSM US Alliance provides its members with access to resources of RSM US LLP. RSM US Alliance member firms are separate and independent businesses and legal entities that are responsible for their own acts and omissions, and each is separate and independent from RSM US LLP. RSM US LLP is the U.S. member firm of RSM International, a global network of independent audit, tax, and consulting firms. Members of RSM US Alliance have access to RSM International resources through RSM US LLP but are not member firms of RSM International. Visit rsmus.com/about us for more information regarding RSM US LLP and RSM International. The RSM logo is used under license by RSM US LLP. RSM US Alliance products and services are proprietary to RSM US LLP.
LaPorte is a proud member of the RSM US Alliance, a premier affiliation of independent accounting and consulting firms in the United States. RSM US Alliance provides our firm with access to resources of RSM US LLP, the leading provider of audit, tax and consulting services focused on the middle market. RSM US LLP is a licensed CPA firm and the U.S. member of RSM International, a global network of independent audit, tax and consulting firms with more than 43,000 people in over 120 countries.
Our membership in RSM US Alliance has elevated our capabilities in the marketplace, helping to differentiate our firm from the competition while allowing us to maintain our independence and entrepreneurial culture. We have access to a valuable peer network of like-sized firms as well as a broad range of tools, expertise, and technical resources.
For more information on how LaPorte can assist you, please call 713.548.2034.